Montauk, New York: Best Things to Do – Top Picks

Did you know Montauk is home to New York State’s oldest lighthouse, commissioned by President George Washington in 1796 and still guiding ships today? Perched at the easternmost tip of Long Island, this charming coastal hamlet known as “The End” offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, outdoor adventure, and laid-back beach vibes that sets it apart from its glitzier Hamptons neighbors.

Planning Your Montauk Adventure

Before diving into the best things to do in Montauk, let’s cover some essential travel planning information to ensure your visit goes smoothly. From transportation options to the ideal time for your trip, these tips will help you make the most of your Montauk experience.

Getting to Montauk

Located approximately 120 miles from New York City, Montauk is accessible by car, train, bus, or seasonal ferry. The drive from NYC takes about 3 hours, depending on traffic (which can be heavy during summer weekends). For a car-free option, the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) offers service to Montauk station, or you can take the Hampton Jitney coach bus service, which provides a comfortable ride with amenities.

Best Time to Visit

Montauk’s high season runs from Memorial Day to Labor Day (late May through early September), when the weather is warmest and all businesses are open. However, this is also when crowds are heaviest and prices highest. For a more peaceful experience with still-pleasant weather, consider the shoulder seasons: mid-May to late June or September through mid-October. Many locals prefer September, when the ocean is still warm but the summer crowds have thinned.

Where to Stay in Montauk

Montauk offers accommodations for every style and budget, from luxury oceanfront resorts to charming motels and inns. Most properties are within walking distance of beaches, restaurants, and shops, making it easy to explore without a car once you’ve arrived.

Top Attractions in Montauk

Montauk Point Lighthouse

No visit to Montauk is complete without seeing the iconic Montauk Point Lighthouse, New York State’s oldest lighthouse and a National Historic Landmark. Commissioned by President George Washington in 1796, the lighthouse offers breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean from its 110-foot tower. The museum inside features fascinating maritime artifacts and historical exhibits. For the best photos, take the path adjacent to the entrance down to the rocky beach for a stunning perspective of the lighthouse against the dramatic coastline.

Beaches

Montauk boasts some of the finest beaches on Long Island, each with its own distinct character. Ditch Plains Beach is a legendary surf spot with consistent waves and dramatic bluffs. Kirk Park Beach offers convenient access to town with lifeguards and facilities. Gin Beach features calmer waters ideal for families with young children. For a more secluded experience, head to the beaches within the state parks. Note that during summer, town beaches require parking permits, so consider staying at a beachfront hotel or using alternative transportation.

State Parks

Montauk is home to six state parks, offering everything from hiking and biking trails to fishing spots and campgrounds. Camp Hero State Park features dramatic bluffs with views of the lighthouse and a mysterious former military base that inspired the show “Stranger Things.” Shadmoor State Park offers scenic hiking trails along oceanfront bluffs. Hither Hills State Park provides camping facilities and the unique “Walking Dunes” formation. Amsterdam Beach State Park and Montauk Point State Park offer more rugged coastal experiences, while Montauk Downs State Park features a championship golf course.

Unique Montauk Experiences

Sunset Sailing

Experience Montauk from the water with a sunset sail aboard the Mon Tiki catamarans. These locally-built, Polynesian-inspired vessels offer a magical way to end your day, with breathtaking views of the coastline bathed in golden light. Choose from group cruises or private charters for a more intimate experience. The knowledgeable crew enhances the journey with local insights and sailing expertise.

Beach Bonfires

A beloved Montauk tradition is gathering around a beach bonfire as the sun sets. From Memorial Day to Labor Day, bonfires are permitted after 6 p.m. in metal containers on public beaches. Bring blankets, chairs, and ingredients for s’mores, then settle in for an evening of conversation and stargazing. It’s a perfect way to experience Montauk’s relaxed beach culture and create lasting memories.

Horseback Riding

For a unique perspective of Montauk’s natural beauty, book a horseback riding experience at Deep Hollow Ranch, which claims to be the oldest working ranch in the United States. Guided trail rides take you through scenic woodlands and along beautiful beaches, offering a peaceful way to connect with nature and see Montauk from a different angle.

Fishing

Known as the “Fishing Capital of the World,” Montauk offers exceptional opportunities for anglers of all skill levels. Charter a private fishing boat or join a group excursion from Montauk Harbor with reputable operators like Viking Fleet or Miss Montauk II. Depending on the season, you might catch striped bass, bluefish, tuna, or fluke. Even if you’re new to fishing, the experienced captains ensure an enjoyable and often successful day on the water.

Dining and Nightlife

Seafood and Dining

Montauk’s dining scene ranges from casual seafood shacks to upscale restaurants, with fresh-caught seafood starring on most menus. For the quintessential Montauk experience, try The Lobster Roll (nicknamed “LUNCH” for its iconic sign), serving perfect lobster rolls since the 1960s. Duryea’s Lobster Deck offers waterfront dining with a Mediterranean influence. For upscale options, Scarpetta Beach at Gurney’s and Navy Beach provide sophisticated menus with stunning views. Don’t miss Montauk’s food trucks and casual spots like John’s Drive-In for homemade ice cream.

Breakfast and Coffee

Start your day at Montauk Bake Shoppe for their famous jelly croissants and quality coffee. Joni’s offers healthy options with organic ingredients, while Anthony’s Pancake House serves classic diner breakfast fare. For specialty coffee, Bluestone Lane provides Australian-inspired coffee culture with ocean views.

Bars and Nightlife

Montauk’s nightlife has evolved from quiet fishing village to vibrant scene, while still maintaining its laid-back charm. The Montauket offers the best sunset views with reasonably priced drinks. The Surf Lodge hosts live music and becomes a see-and-be-seen hotspot in summer. For a more local experience, The Hideaway provides a classic dive bar atmosphere. Newer additions like Ruschmeyers and Bounce Beach Montauk offer dancing and DJ sets. During peak season, expect lines at popular spots, so arrive early or make reservations when possible.

Local Brews

Don’t leave without visiting Montauk Brewing Company’s tasting room in the heart of town. Sample their refreshing Summer Ale, Wave Chaser IPA, or Driftwood Ale in a casual, dog-friendly space. The brewery embodies Montauk’s “come as you are” spirit and offers a perfect post-beach refreshment.

Practical Tips for Visiting Montauk

Experience the Magic of Montauk

Montauk offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, outdoor adventure, and laid-back beach culture that makes it a truly special destination. Whether you’re surfing at Ditch Plains, watching the sunset from Montauk Point Lighthouse, enjoying fresh seafood by the harbor, or simply relaxing on the beach, Montauk’s charm will capture your heart and leave you planning your return before you’ve even left.

Unlike its glitzier Hamptons neighbors, Montauk maintains a more relaxed, authentic atmosphere where flip-flops are always appropriate and the natural landscape takes center stage. From families building sandcastles to surfers chasing the perfect wave, fishermen hauling in the day’s catch to couples toasting the sunset, Montauk welcomes all who appreciate its unique spirit at “The End” of Long Island.