Hotels by Trip.com
Flights by Trip.com
Did you know that Scilly Cay, a tiny island measuring just 200 m² (0.05 acres), attracts thousands of visitors annually for its legendary lobster feasts and rum punch? This minuscule private island off Anguilla’s northeastern coast has transformed from a barren cay in 1985 to one of the Caribbean’s most beloved lunch destinations, serving up unforgettable seafood and island vibes that keep travelers coming back year after year.
Getting There & Planning Your Journey
Reaching this slice of paradise requires a bit of planning, but the journey is part of the charm. First, you’ll need to get to Anguilla, which is accessible by air or sea from nearby islands.
Once on Anguilla, make your way to Island Harbour on the northeastern coast. From there, you have several options to reach Scilly Cay:
Ferry Service
The most common way to reach Scilly Cay is via the island’s ferry service from Island Harbour. Simply stand on the dock and wave to the island – they’ll send a boat to pick you up. The round trip costs just US$5 per person and takes about 2 minutes each way.
No reservation is needed for the ferry, but it’s wise to call ahead to confirm the restaurant is open, especially during off-season or inclement weather.
Shuttle Service
If you’re staying on the western end of Anguilla, Scilly Cay offers a shuttle service in partnership with local taxi companies. The flat rate is US$35 per person round trip from the west end, with discounted rates available for larger groups.
This option saves you the hassle of renting a car or finding your own transportation to Island Harbour.
Private Boats
For those with access to private boats or charter vessels, Scilly Cay has a small dock that can accommodate vessels with a 3-4 ft draft. Alternatively, you can beach your boat on their small sandy shore.
If you’re navigating yourself, the Scilly Cay team is happy to provide guidance to ensure a safe arrival.
✓ Check 30,000+ Local Sightseeing Tours Worldwide
Best Time to Visit Anguilla
Timing your visit to Scilly Cay requires understanding both Anguilla’s seasonal patterns and the restaurant’s operating schedule.
Recommended Months
- December to April – Peak season with perfect weather (26-29°C/78-84°F), minimal rainfall, and consistent trade winds
- May – Shoulder season with good weather and fewer crowds
- November – Beginning of high season with gradually improving weather
Months to Avoid
- June to October – Hurricane season with higher risk of storms and rainfall
- August to September – Peak hurricane months when some businesses (including Scilly Cay) may close temporarily
- Late summer – Hottest period with temperatures reaching 32°C (90°F)
Important: Scilly Cay is open only on Wednesdays, Thursdays, and Sundays from 11:00 AM to 5:30 PM. The restaurant may close during the low season (typically August-September). Always call ahead to confirm they’re open: +1(264)-235-5000.
Getting Around Locally
Once you’ve arrived in Anguilla, you’ll need to navigate to Island Harbour to catch the ferry to Scilly Cay. Here are your best options for local transportation:
Rental Cars
The most flexible option for exploring Anguilla. Rental cars are widely available at the airport and ferry terminal. Expect to pay US$40-60 per day. Remember that driving is on the left side of the road in Anguilla.
Taxis
Taxis are readily available but can be expensive for multiple trips. A one-way fare from the west end to Island Harbour costs approximately US$25-30. Some taxi drivers offer island tours for around US$75 per hour.
Scilly Cay Shuttle
The restaurant offers a shuttle service in partnership with local taxis. For US$35 per person round trip from the west end, they’ll pick you up from your accommodation and return you after your visit.
Pro tip: If you’re planning to explore other parts of Anguilla during your stay, renting a car is the most cost-effective option. However, if Scilly Cay is your only excursion, the shuttle service provides excellent value.
Where to Stay
While Scilly Cay itself doesn’t offer accommodations, there are plenty of excellent options on Anguilla’s main island, ranging from luxury resorts to charming guesthouses.
Luxury Resorts
Anguilla is renowned for its high-end accommodations that offer world-class amenities and service. Most luxury resorts are located on the western end of the island, about 20-30 minutes drive from Island Harbour.
- Expect rates from US$500-1,500+ per night during high season
- Most offer restaurants, spas, pools, and beach access
- Many can arrange transportation to Scilly Cay
Boutique Hotels & Villas
For a more intimate experience, Anguilla offers numerous boutique properties and private villas that provide personalized service in unique settings.
- Rates typically range from US$250-800 per night
- Many villas offer multiple bedrooms, making them ideal for families or groups
- Often include kitchen facilities for self-catering
Budget-Friendly Options
While Anguilla is known for luxury, there are more affordable accommodations available, particularly in the Island Harbour area close to Scilly Cay.
- Guesthouses and apartments from US$150-250 per night
- Often family-run with authentic local hospitality
- Staying in Island Harbour puts you within walking distance of the Scilly Cay ferry
Dining & Local Cuisine
The dining experience is the heart and soul of Scilly Cay, with a simple yet extraordinary menu that has earned international acclaim.
The Scilly Cay Menu
The restaurant offers a straightforward menu focused on perfectly executed grilled seafood and meats. Everything is prepared fresh on open grills without electricity – just the way it’s been done for decades.
Signature Dishes
- Grilled Lobster – The star attraction, brushed with garlic butter and grilled to perfection
- Grilled Crayfish – A local favorite, similar to lobster but with sweeter meat
- Chicken with Peanut Sauce – Tender chicken breast with a unique, flavorful sauce
- Brown Sugar Pork Ribs – Sweet and savory ribs with a Caribbean twist
Drinks & Extras
- Rum Punch – Legendarily potent and delicious at US$10
- Beer – Cold local and international options
- Vegetarian Plate – Curried chickpeas, fresh vegetables, and salad
- Cookie Flower – A decadent dessert featuring local cookies and pudding
Dining Tips: Meals at Scilly Cay are not inexpensive (lobster runs US$45-65 depending on size), but portions are generous and the experience is unparalleled. There’s no need to make reservations, but arriving before noon ensures you’ll get a prime table by the water.
Beyond Scilly Cay
While Scilly Cay is a must-visit dining destination, Anguilla offers numerous other culinary experiences worth exploring:
- Island Harbour Restaurants – Several excellent seafood spots are located in the fishing village near the Scilly Cay dock
- Food Trucks & Roadside BBQs – For authentic local flavors at budget-friendly prices
- Fine Dining – Anguilla boasts several world-class restaurants, particularly in the Shoal Bay and Meads Bay areas
Attractions, Sightseeing & Activities
While the dining experience is the main attraction, Scilly Cay offers several activities to enjoy during your visit.
Snorkeling
The waters around Scilly Cay offer excellent snorkeling opportunities. The island is surrounded by extensive grass beds and reefs that are home to rays, turtles, colorful fish, and even lobsters. You can snorkel around the entire island for a comprehensive underwater tour.
Beach Relaxation
Scilly Cay has a small but pristine beach area where you can sunbathe, swim, or simply relax in the Caribbean breeze. Beach chairs are available, and the calm waters within the bay are perfect for a refreshing dip.
Live Entertainment
On Sundays, Scilly Cay features live music that creates the perfect island atmosphere. Wednesdays and Thursdays offer house music. The entertainment enhances the laid-back vibe that makes Scilly Cay special.
Nearby Attractions
While visiting Scilly Cay, take time to explore the surrounding area of Island Harbour and eastern Anguilla:
- Island Harbour Fishing Village – Watch local fishermen bring in their daily catch and experience authentic Anguillian culture
- Shoal Bay East – One of the world’s most beautiful beaches is just a short drive away
- The Old Salt Factory and Pump House – Historical site showcasing Anguilla’s salt-producing past
- Big Spring Cave – Ancient Amerindian petroglyphs in a natural cave setting
Museums, Cultural Spots & Festivals
While Scilly Cay itself doesn’t have museums, understanding Anguilla’s rich cultural heritage enhances your visit to this iconic spot.
Cultural Attractions
- Heritage Collection Museum – Located in East End, this small but comprehensive museum showcases Anguilla’s history and culture
- Wallblake House – The island’s only surviving plantation house, offering a glimpse into colonial history
- Anguilla National Trust – Provides information on the island’s natural and cultural heritage
Festivals & Events
Anguilla hosts several vibrant festivals throughout the year that celebrate the island’s culture, music, and cuisine:
Annual Events
- Anguilla Summer Festival (August) – The island’s biggest celebration featuring boat races, parades, and beach parties
- Moonsplash Music Festival (March) – A renowned reggae festival held at The Dune Preserve
- Festival Del Mar (Easter weekend) – Celebrates Anguilla’s seafaring heritage in Island Harbour
Ongoing Cultural Experiences
- Sandy Ground Beach Bars – Live music and local gatherings
- Thursday Night Fish Fry – Community event in various locations
- Art Galleries – Featuring work by local artists throughout the island
If your visit coincides with Festival Del Mar in Island Harbour, you’ll have the perfect opportunity to combine a trip to Scilly Cay with authentic local celebrations just across the water.
Sports, Nature & Outdoor Experiences
Beyond Scilly Cay’s immediate offerings, Anguilla provides numerous opportunities for outdoor enthusiasts.
Water Activities
- Snorkeling & Diving – Explore Anguilla’s coral reefs, underwater caves, and marine life
- Sailing & Boat Tours – Charter a boat for island hopping to nearby Prickly Pear, Dog Island, or even St. Martin
- Kiteboarding & Windsurfing – Consistent trade winds make Anguilla ideal for these sports
- Paddleboarding – Perfect in the calm waters of many of Anguilla’s bays
Land Activities
- Hiking – Explore coastal trails and nature reserves
- Bird Watching – Anguilla is home to over 130 bird species
- Golf – The island features a Greg Norman-designed 18-hole championship course
- Tennis – Many resorts offer courts with professional instruction
Safety, Etiquette & Local Customs
Understanding local customs and safety considerations will enhance your visit to Scilly Cay and Anguilla.
Safety Tips
- Sun Protection – The Caribbean sun is intense. Bring reef-safe sunscreen, hats, and sunglasses
- Hydration – Drink plenty of water, especially if enjoying Scilly Cay’s famous rum punch
- Water Safety – While the waters around Scilly Cay are generally calm, always be aware of your swimming abilities
- Valuables – Keep valuables to a minimum when visiting the cay, as storage options are limited
Local Etiquette
- Greetings – Anguillians are friendly; a simple “Good morning” or “Good afternoon” is appreciated
- Dress Code – Casual beach attire is fine for Scilly Cay, but bring a cover-up for the boat ride
- Photography – Always ask permission before photographing locals
- Tipping – 15-20% is customary for good service
Scilly Cay and Anguilla operate on “island time” – service may be more relaxed than you’re accustomed to. Embrace the pace and enjoy the laid-back atmosphere that makes the Caribbean special.
Practical Travel Tips
Make the most of your visit to Scilly Cay with these essential practical tips.
Money Matters
- Currency – Scilly Cay accepts US Dollars, Eastern Caribbean Dollars, and Euros
- Payment Methods – Credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, American Express) are accepted, as are local checks
- Pricing – Expect to pay US$45-65 for lobster, US$35-45 for chicken or ribs, and US$10 for rum punch
- ATMs – There are no ATMs on Scilly Cay; withdraw cash in The Valley or other main areas of Anguilla
Planning Your Visit
- Opening Hours – Wednesdays, Thursdays, and Sundays from 11:00 AM to 5:30 PM
- Reservations – Not required for regular dining, but recommended for large groups
- Contact – Call +1(264)-235-5000 to confirm opening or arrange transportation
- Duration – Plan to spend at least 2-3 hours to fully enjoy the experience
What to Bring
- Beach Essentials – Swimwear, towel, sunscreen, hat, and sunglasses
- Snorkeling Gear – Bring your own if you have it (limited rentals may be available)
- Camera – The views are spectacular and worth capturing
- Cash – While cards are accepted, cash is always good to have on hand
Experience the Magic of Scilly Cay
From its humble beginnings as a barren cay to its current status as an Anguilla institution, Scilly Cay offers a quintessential Caribbean experience that combines exceptional food, breathtaking surroundings, and authentic island hospitality. Whether you’re savoring their famous lobster, snorkeling in crystal-clear waters, or simply relaxing with a rum punch in hand, a day at Scilly Cay is sure to become a highlight of your Anguilla vacation.
Ready to unwind on Anguilla’s hidden gem? Start planning your Scilly Cay escape today and discover why this tiny island paradise keeps travelers coming back year after year!
