Did you know that Sugarloaf Key is home to the remains of the historic Sugarloaf Key Bat Tower, one of only 14 ever built in the United States? This 30-foot wooden structure was constructed in 1929 to control mosquitoes naturally but never attracted a single bat. While the original tower collapsed during Hurricane Irma in 2017, its legacy lives on as part of the unique history that makes this Lower Florida Keys gem so special.
Getting There & Planning Your Journey
Sugarloaf Key sits at mile marker 17-20 on the Overseas Highway (US-1), approximately 32 km (20 miles) east of Key West. The two closest airports are:
- Key West International Airport (EYW) – Just 24 km (15 miles) away, offering the most convenient access with flights from major cities.
- Miami International Airport (MIA) – Located about 217 km (135 miles) away, providing more flight options and often better prices.
The scenic drive from Miami to Sugarloaf Key takes approximately 3 hours along the stunning Overseas Highway, crossing 42 bridges with breathtaking ocean views on both sides.
Best Time to Visit Sugarloaf Key & Weather Tips
Sugarloaf Key enjoys a tropical climate with warm temperatures year-round, but timing your visit can make a big difference in your experience:
| Season | Months | Temperature | Crowds | Notes |
| Peak Season | December-April | 21-27°C (70-80°F) | High | Perfect weather, higher prices |
| Shoulder Season | May, November | 24-30°C (75-86°F) | Moderate | Good balance of weather and value |
| Low Season | June-October | 27-32°C (80-90°F) | Low | Hurricane season, humid, best deals |
Recommended: Late November to early April offers the best combination of pleasant weather and outdoor activity conditions.
Avoid: August through October, which is peak hurricane season with high humidity and frequent afternoon thunderstorms.
Getting Around Locally
Navigating Sugarloaf Key and the surrounding Lower Keys is straightforward but requires some planning:
Rental Car
The most convenient option for exploring at your own pace. Having a car gives you the freedom to visit nearby keys and attractions without depending on schedules.
Bicycles & Scooters
Perfect for short distances and exploring the key itself. Many accommodations offer rentals, and there are dedicated rental shops on the key.
Taxis & Rideshares
Available but limited. Pre-arrange rides or save local taxi numbers, as rideshare services have limited availability in the Lower Keys.
Where to Stay in Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Key offers a range of accommodation options to suit different preferences and budgets:
Sugarloaf Key Resort Marina
The premier resort option on the key, offering waterfront cottages, marina access, and amenities like a pool and restaurant. Perfect for boaters and those seeking convenience.
Price range: $$$-$$$$
Vacation Rentals
The most popular option in Sugarloaf Key, with numerous waterfront homes featuring private docks, pools, and stunning views. Ideal for families and longer stays.
Price range: $$-$$$$
Nearby Options
Key West (20 minutes away) and Big Pine Key (10 minutes away) offer additional accommodation choices, from luxury resorts to budget-friendly motels.
Price range: $-$$$$
Dining & Local Cuisine
The culinary scene in Sugarloaf Key and the surrounding Lower Keys celebrates fresh seafood and tropical flavors. Here are the top dining experiences to enjoy:
Must-Try Local Specialties
- Fresh Catch of the Day – Locally caught yellowtail snapper, mahi-mahi, and grouper
- Stone Crab Claws – A Florida Keys delicacy (seasonal from October to May)
- Conch Fritters – Deep-fried conch meat mixed with spices and vegetables
- Key Lime Pie – The iconic dessert of the Florida Keys
Top Dining Spots
Mangrove Mama’s
A local favorite on nearby Sugarloaf Boulevard, known for its casual atmosphere, seafood platters, and Key lime pie. Don’t miss their conch fritters and fish tacos.
Square Grouper Bar & Grill
Located on Cudjoe Key (just a few minutes away), offering upscale seafood dishes and craft cocktails with waterfront views.
Kiki’s Sandbar
On Little Torch Key, this waterfront spot is famous for its tuna nachos and relaxed atmosphere. Great for sunset drinks and casual dining.
Sugarloaf Food Company
A local market and deli perfect for picking up picnic supplies, sandwiches, and essentials for your stay.
Attractions, Sightseeing & Activities in Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Key offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, water activities, and proximity to other Lower Keys attractions. Here are the best things to do during your visit:
Water Adventures
Kayaking the Mangrove Trails
Explore the intricate waterways and mangrove tunnels surrounding Sugarloaf Key. Rentals are available at Sugarloaf Marina, or join a guided eco-tour to learn about the unique ecosystem.
Fishing
The waters around Sugarloaf Key are a fisherman’s paradise. Target tarpon, permit, bonefish in the flats, or head to deeper waters for mahi-mahi and grouper. Charter services are available, or fish from shore at several access points.
Nearby Attractions
Great White Heron National Wildlife Refuge
This 200,000-acre sanctuary is accessible by boat from Sugarloaf Key. It’s home to numerous bird species, including the rare white morph of the great blue heron.
Bat Tower Historic Site
Visit the site of the historic Sugarloaf Bat Tower. While the original structure collapsed in 2017, interpretive signs explain its fascinating history and purpose.
Sugarloaf Sound
This shallow bay area on the Atlantic side offers excellent paddleboarding, wildlife viewing, and photography opportunities, especially at sunrise.
Exploring Nearby Keys
One of the best things to do in Sugarloaf Key is to use it as a base for exploring the surrounding Lower Keys, each with its own unique character and attractions:
Big Pine Key (10 min)
Home to the National Key Deer Refuge where you can spot the endangered Key deer, a miniature subspecies of white-tailed deer found nowhere else in the world.
Don’t miss: Blue Hole (an abandoned quarry now home to alligators and birds) and No Name Pub (a historic restaurant with dollar bills covering the walls).
Bahia Honda State Park (15 min)
Features one of the most beautiful beaches in the Florida Keys with crystal-clear waters perfect for swimming and snorkeling.
The park also offers great views of the historic Bahia Honda Rail Bridge, part of Flagler’s Overseas Railroad.
Key West (20 min)
The famous southernmost city offers attractions like Duval Street, Hemingway House, Mallory Square sunset celebration, and the Southernmost Point Buoy.
Staying in Sugarloaf Key gives you easy access to Key West’s attractions without the crowds and higher prices.
Sports, Nature & Outdoor Experiences
The natural environment around Sugarloaf Key provides endless opportunities for outdoor recreation and wildlife encounters:
Water Sports
- Snorkeling & Diving – Looe Key Reef, just a short boat ride away, offers some of the best snorkeling and diving in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary.
- Paddleboarding – Explore the calm waters and mangrove trails on a stand-up paddleboard. Rentals available at Sugarloaf Marina.
- Jet Skiing – Rent jet skis to explore the surrounding waters at higher speeds. Several rental companies operate in the area.
Wildlife Encounters
Bird Watching
The Lower Keys are a birder’s paradise with over 250 species. Look for ospreys, pelicans, herons, egrets, and frigatebirds. Dawn and dusk offer the best viewing opportunities.
Marine Life
Keep an eye out for dolphins, manatees, rays, and sea turtles while boating or kayaking. The waters around Sugarloaf Key are teeming with marine life year-round.
Safety, Etiquette & Local Customs
Ensure a safe and respectful visit to Sugarloaf Key with these important guidelines:
Safety Tips
- Sun Protection – The Florida Keys sun is intense year-round. Wear reef-safe sunscreen (SPF 30+), a hat, sunglasses, and UV-protective clothing.
- Hydration – Drink plenty of water, especially when engaging in outdoor activities.
- Water Safety – Be aware of currents and weather conditions before swimming or boating. Always have life jackets available.
- Wildlife – Observe wildlife from a respectful distance. Never feed wild animals, including birds and fish.
- Hurricane Awareness – If visiting during hurricane season (June-November), stay informed about weather forecasts and evacuation procedures.
Environmental Etiquette
The Florida Keys ecosystem is fragile and protected. Please follow these guidelines:
- Use reef-safe sunscreen to protect coral reefs
- Stay in marked channels when boating to avoid damaging seagrass beds
- Take all trash with you, especially from beaches and waterways
- Respect wildlife by maintaining a safe distance and never feeding animals
- Follow catch-and-release practices when fishing unless keeping fish for consumption
Visitor Comments About Sugarloaf Key
“We rented a waterfront home on Sugarloaf Key and it was the perfect base for exploring the Lower Keys. Kayaking through the mangroves was magical – we spotted herons, fish, and even a manatee! The laid-back atmosphere is exactly what we needed for a relaxing vacation.”
“Sugarloaf Key offers the best of both worlds – peaceful seclusion but just a short drive to Key West. We loved fishing from our rental’s private dock and cooking our catch for dinner. Don’t miss the nearby Bat Tower site and the amazing snorkeling at Looe Key!”
“As international visitors, we found Sugarloaf Key to be a true slice of American paradise. The locals were friendly, the seafood was incredible, and the natural beauty was breathtaking. Renting a car is essential, but the freedom to explore the surrounding keys made our trip unforgettable.”
Practical Travel Tips
What to Pack
- Lightweight, breathable clothing
- Multiple swimsuits
- Water shoes for rocky beaches and kayaking
- Reef-safe sunscreen and insect repellent
- Waterproof phone case or dry bag
- Snorkeling gear (though rentals are available)
- Binoculars for wildlife viewing
Money-Saving Tips
- Book accommodations well in advance, especially for winter months
- Consider visiting during shoulder season (May or November)
- Rent a vacation home with a kitchen to save on dining costs
- Purchase groceries in Key West or Marathon, as options are limited on Sugarloaf
- Bring your own snorkeling gear and fishing equipment if possible
- Look for combo tour packages that include multiple activities
Connectivity
Cell service is generally good throughout Sugarloaf Key, but may be spotty in some areas, especially on the water. Most accommodations offer Wi-Fi, though it may not be as fast as you’re used to. Consider downloading maps, guides, and entertainment before your trip.
Your Sugarloaf Adventure Awaits
Sugarloaf Key offers a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure in the stunning Florida Keys. From kayaking through mangrove tunnels to spotting unique wildlife, fishing in world-class waters, and exploring nearby attractions, this Lower Keys gem provides an authentic Florida Keys experience away from the crowds. Whether you’re seeking outdoor adventures, wildlife encounters, or simply a peaceful tropical getaway, Sugarloaf Key delivers with its natural beauty and laid-back island atmosphere. Start planning your trip today and discover why this hidden treasure is one of the best-kept secrets in the Florida Keys.
0 Comments